It all started under the dome shaped dryer at Bubbles. I was there getting my hair highlighted. My stylist had just finished foiling my hair and had lead me over to the row of dryers where I’d spend some ten or fifteen minutes waiting. Since I currently do not like to be alone with my thoughts (I think I’ve mentioned this here before . . . inactivity makes me uncomfortable) and because I am a chatterbox, I made a few phone calls. Yes, I made phone calls from under the dryer. I scheduled a physical, called my husband, and even left a message for my mother. When these calls were done, alone with my thoughts, I picked up a magazine. I flipped the pages of Vanity Fair reading about beauty treatments, fashion, health, and then stumbled upon an article by Suze Orman. I have to be honest, I’m not sure why I read the article. I don’t much care for thinking about money; in fact, my family’s finances are handled almost entirely by my husband. Anyway, Suze wrote about taking control of my finances in 2010, or 2009, I can’t remember if it was an old or new copy. Again, I don’t usually like to think, talk about, or reflect on money. My role in our family tends to be that of “investor.” I invest in kids’ toys, chocolate milk, home ware, cleaning products, beauty products, health products, music, food, and if possible, camera equipment.
I wasn’t always like this. Ten years ago, I remember saving every dollar and penny I earned from my multiple jobs for a rainy day. I didn’t know what my rainy day would involve, but I just wanted to make sure that should I need it, I’d have a few dollars saved up. When it came to clothes, I shopped at second hand shops, wore my sister and mother’s hand-me-downs, and waited until holidays for new items. I often refer to this stage in my life as “my ascetism.” I wasn’t exactly the happiest person during this time in my life; I felt disconnected, in a way, from other people. At least where I grew up (here in the United States), materialism is a way of life. By barring myself of having things, I noticed that I felt “different.” Even my father, who I remember as being, let’s say, attentive to our family’s finances, asked me to to lighten up and enjoy life a little bit. He said I needed to live my life. I was in my early twenties, feeling philosophical, doubtful, and worried. I didn’t know what “live” meant.
I won’t say that I miraculously changed overnight. There was a period, probably early in my relationship with my husband, when I would allow myself to have things here and there. I remember getting a pedicure, trying to enjoy the experience, feeling riddled with guilt the entire time. A few months before we were engaged, my husband invited me to attend a vacation wedding with him at a resort in Jamaica. The entire time we were there, I complained that I didn’t like having people wait on me. I didn’t want someone to bring me a glass of champagne. If I wanted champagne, I would get a glass for myself. He says I nearly ruined that trip. While I regret being unappreciative of the great gift he was giving me (a chance to see a new place, meet new people, observe wildlife, and spend time with him), I suspect that my inability to enjoy the gift had something to do with my family background: I grew up in a working class family. Both my parents worked long and hard hours; if either my sister and I wanted something, we worked for it. Accepting gifts somehow seemed wrong.
When I became a mother and became environmentally concerned (conscious), I returned, on some levels, to the a life style I’d known years earlier: the life of making do without. In part, I think I felt incredibly lucky to be at home with my daughter; I knew that being with her for all the small moments was priceless . . . and yet, again, I felt uncomfortable with accepting the gift my husband was giving me, giving my daughter too: the gift of time. Time for her to have her mother’s attention, time for me to just spend hours staring at my baby. At the same time, I wanted to make sure that I wasn’t enjoying my time at home too much. Even now, when I walk through my house picking up toys, socks, and dishes and bowls left here and there, I think to myself, this is how I am serving the world: I am serving my family.
But again, I wonder, do I take it too far? During my first two years at home with Annabelle, I shopped only at secondhand shops and would only welcome “brand spanking new” items into my life when they were gifts. I’m not claiming that I was some kind of saint or anything, but I do know that I’d even wait until the holidays for new underwear because I knew that my mother would buy me a few pairs . . . I wanted to save money, reduce my impact upon our planet, and feel good in that I didn’t “need” anything.
The truth was and is that I do have needs. We all do. As you might’ve noticed in recent posts, I have, to some extent, done a 180. I no longer have an aversion to shopping. My husband might say that that is an understatement. I accept that I every now and again I want to treat myself to Starbucks and a pair of new earrings. Many of my therapy sessions in these past six months have dealt with the fact that I have trouble giving to myself. At one session, I remember my therapist clapping her hands because I told her that on a whim, I walked into Victoria’s Secret and bought myself a bra and underwear. I even came home with a fragrance.
Over time, though, in these most recent months, I worry that I have become too comfortable with spending money: I’ve become a shopping queen. To find out just how much I am spending, I tracked all of my expenses for the past 2 weeks. I really didn’t think it would be so bad, but I’ve got to tell you, I could not believe how much money I’d spent! Items purchased included a new bedspread, new carmats, childcare, highlights and a haircut (where Suze Orman made me get all financially-aware and everything), lots of chocolate milk and tea (on outings with the kids), Annabelle’s ballet class, books . . . I’d spent a small fortune. During two weeks time, I’d spent enough to buy a decent lens for my camera.
So I dialed up my best friend and told her. She too enjoys shopping. We like to shop together. We find neat things together. But lately, even she has commented that shopping can get out of control. She immediately reminded me of Crunchy Chicken’s Buy Nothing Challenge, which I’d participated in a few summers ago. During that summer month, I abstained from any non-food purchase. If I remember correctly, my husband even felt annoyed with me because I was participating in the challenge during one of our family vacations and I made a huge deal about not buying anything.
To get to my point, I am going to once again participate in a month of not buying anything. While I am not going to set up a challenge like the Crunchy Chicken has done, I will invite you to encourage me, join me, or just leave your 2 cents as I embark on a month long adventure of saying no to stuff. My plan is to write down all the items that I think that I want to buy and to then evaluate my list at the end of the month. I’m pretty sure that I won’t have needed nor wanted all that is on the list by the end of the month.
P.S. I’ve asked my husband to be supportive, and I know, with great certainty, that he’s pretty happy I am challenging myself to reign in my spending. That said, I do not want to not do for myself . . . know what I’m saying?
Moderation is key.


{ 12 comments }
I have to say that I love Suze Orman and we watch her show all the time. Ed and I saved, saved, saved for years then blew all of our savings when we built our house. So we’re back to being misers now, especially with the baby on the way. I’m the financial person in our family (I’m controlling that way), and I hardly ever can justify spending money on myself, especially now that I needed to buy a car!
Would you believe that the only clothes I bought for myself since becoming pregnant back in July are maternity underwear (about 2 months ago, when I could not longer squeeze into my old underwear) and a few nursing bras? I even used my Christmas gift cards to buy them! All my other maternity clothes were bought by my mom and mom-in-law, or given to me by a friend. And I don’t have a ton of them… maybe 4 pairs of pants and a dozen tops. Kind of funny for someone who has to dress “professionally” at work. I just couldn’t imagine spending money on them.
abbie, as someone who inherited many maternity clothes and just passed on bags to a pregnant friend, I totally understand your resistance to spending on new maternity clothes. That said, I struggled so much with how I felt about my appearance during my pregnancy and every now and again, purchasing myself a top that fit and flattered me, made me feel good about my blossoming and changing body. Does that make sense?
I understand the “miser” mindset too; I am not sure I get to the point I think I wanted to lie within this article, which is that, it is okay to live in the now and do for ourselves right now . . . rather than always preparing for tomorrow. I guess what I am getting at is that there is some value in striking a balance in enjoying life and planning for the future.
Oh, and I wore one pair of pants for the last two months of pregnancy. I donated them . . . I didn’t want anyone I personally knew to see how stretched out they were, lol. So vain, huh? ;-)
Haha! Yeah, I wore the same one pair of pants to work, every day, for the last month or so. So glad I’m not working anymore :)
I do agree that it’s okay to splurge. We totally splurged on our house, and now we’re back to miser-ville.
I favor Dave Ramsey for budgeting advice. The category I like best is the one titled BLOW. I guess you could call it allowance or whatnot but the key is it is planned in unplanned spending money. His entire approach to budgeting finally got us past the checkbook tracking into actually planning how much and where we spend our money. We did not deny ourself of ‘luxuries’ like clothing, car repairs, and cloth diapers. or even eating out. We spend almost $1000 in those areas last month. The key was it is planned.
Maybe what you should do this month is write down everything you think you should buy. Then April first decide which items you should really buy and how much they will cost and only buy those items. Then during the month of April write a list of items to think of buying in May.
Another thing. Don’t make a big deal of not spending and have it affect those around you. Eilleen over at http://consumption-rebellion.blogspot.com/ did a great job talking about her lack of spending and not having it affect her kids greatly. http://consumption-rebellion.blogspot.com/2009/08/do-no-spend-weeks-really-save-money.html
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:45 pm
Ryan, thank you for directing me to Dave Ramsey and the BLOW category, lol. I’ll definitely check that out. I agree that in reigning in my own spending, I do not want for it to affect my kids. My husband already tends to be pretty thrifty, so I’m not so concerned about him (and my not wanting to spend). For example, I still plan to take my daughter to a play venue that we pay for and to buy her milk and a snack. Also, I like your idea of writing down what I’d like to buy and then wait a month to do so. Definitely going to become a part of my approach to spending.
Abbie – you need to visit Jessica soon, as we’re in peak consignment season around here & maternity clothes are practically given away at these sales! There is one next weekend (last weekend) & many weekends in between till about 4/11.
Jessica, interesting topic, but I also challenge you to spend a little this summer on some of those amazing shows at wolftrap – I haven’t figured out what day I’ll be there with the kids for the children’s theater (we usually go most weeks except two & that’s my huge splurge – the music, theater, dance & educational experiences are much richer than the cost). We’d love to have you as our field trip buddies! I’m already starting my list of other things to do as well :)
We just returned from a fabulously indulgent (but off season) disney world trip. We’ll be visiting miserville shortly :)
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:47 pm
emma, I totally plan to continue “spending” on events, etc. I am simply going to watch my urge to buy “things.” We’d love to join you for wolf trap shows. We love their multicultural festival each summer.
abbie Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 8:17 pm
Baby’s due in a week, so I’m not buying any new clothes! But wow, there’s a lot of consigning there? Here it’s hard to find a good shop. Or I just don’t know where to look.
We’ll join you on the Buy Nothign Challenge, Farzin will love that! I enjoy the Starbucks, the APC, and the shopping, but really I have a cappucino maker at home, and a paid for gym membership that includes childcare. I find myself sometimes using shopping to fill a void, and have struggled with it for years. I buy a bunch of stuff, just random stuff, and it ends up in the trash sooner or later, or sits on a shelf until I give it away. A drain on the wallet, and an emotional drain from the guilt of being so wasteful. Hopefully I can use the time I would spend buying more stuff to fill my already disorganized home to use the things I already have and be more productive, and in turn feel more satisfied with my day.
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:48 pm
I think that I too shop to fill a void . . . if we’re bored or I think I need to change something at home (when really I’m dealing with uncomfortable self-feelings and thoughts). The good thing is that I am not yet in a place where I consider myself a shop-a-holic. Glad you’re joining me this month as I challenge myself to buy nothing!
Oh, and seeds count as groceries, right? ;)
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:48 pm
Totally, ;-) I mean, they eventually become food, right?
I go with the quality over quantity thought for my purchases. So while I didn’t buy loads of “cute tops”, I bought things that would last through several pregnancies, mine or someone else’s. Liam’s toys are few, but quality. And we use cloth because I hate the idea of buying something to poo in it and throw it away… might as well wrap your baby’s heiny in dollar bills!
One area where I should be more mindful of my dollars is the bookstore. I very little self control between the amazing board books and the cookbooks and the leather-bound journals. The other area is the grocery. I would rather buy an amazing eggplant any day over a new top. Switching to a local diet has helped curb my grocery bill. Now… if my husband wouldn’t spend so much money on gaming things. I did talk him into getting one of those power boxes that shuts everything off when the tv goes off… so I guess I’ll count my blessing where I can.
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:50 pm
I want to focus on quality . . . I find that I have trouble purchasing quality clothes for myself because I am a “stay at home” mom and will inevitably be covered in paint, food, spit up, etc. I think, what’s the point? But now I am starting to think that it is okay to purchase good quality items for myself. It’s okay for me to value me.
I love this challange. We did this last year for the first time and agreed to do it at least once a year. It really changed how I look at spending and what we consider “needs.” I also find I enjoy buying the “treats” like Starbucks or a fun bracelet more because it is not mindless shopping but an intentional gift to myself. We too use Dave Ramseys FPU style of money managment and agree the BLOW envelope is wonderful!
Also – just a side note, I greatly enjoy your blog and have you on my blog roll over at http://www.livingforthelaugh.blogspot.com
Good luck, look forward to reading about your months journey!
mamacomedy
Jessica Reply:
March 1st, 2010 at 5:51 pm
I just checked out your blog. I love it! Oh, and I’m going to check out BLOW now that you and Ryan recommended it to me. Thank you for the encouragement!
I have a hard time spending money on myself too, but found that impulse purchases are different from planned ones. In many cases, I could either borrow the item from a friend, or buy it used/refurbished. The Buy Nothing Challenge is great, and I’ll be cheering you on along the way!
I will be here cheering you on. I am a miser, but mostly by choice. The truth is that I prefer to look at money in the bank over shopping. Also, with an 18-month-old in tow shopping is just not a good time. I take him to the grocery store every week and often come home a bundle of nerves.
When I was in university I used to splurge on soap. If I was having a bad week and I needed something nice I would buy the prettiest, best-smelling soap I could find. It was a good balance, because even expensive soap isn’t super-pricey, but it felt like SOMETHING. These days, my weak point is probably kids’ stuff. Luckily, my 18-month-old is no fun to take out in public, so that puts a damper on spending big-time.
Good for you! We have been cutting back for a while now, but I think our no spending month will have to happen after birthday season is over at my house. We tend to have a no spending policy during the summers since my hubby is a teacher and only get paid 9 months of the year. Can you tell we need to work on our budgeting? Luckily I don’t really like shopping, but it is temping to buy stuff when I have to go.
Comments on this entry are closed.